ㅤㅤㅤㅤ
ㅤㅤㅤㅤ

Gun Control On The Pendulum: Both Sides Reach Equilibrium

Jul 20, 2022 3 comments
The Pendulum and Gun Control

The Second Amendment:

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.


Indiana Massacre Stopped By Good Samaritan

Elisha Dicken
Today we will explore how both sides of the political pendulum respond to Second Amendment Rights. On May 24, 2022, nineteenth students and two teachers were shot at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas. The tragedy is both apolitical and atrocious. Whether you swing left or right, what happened in Uvalde is tragic. On July 17, 2022, a mass shooting began in Indiana at the Greenwood Park Mall. The shooter started the massacre at 5:56:48pm but was apprehended at 5:57:03pm. That is a 15-second difference. This is a difference that saved many lives. Elisha Dicken, a 22-year-old male, was the man who stopped the shooter. These two stories have one thing in common: guns kill people, and people kill the shooters. We will not focus on gun reform's legal, political, or personal views. Today, we will look at what news outlets say about the Indiana shooting and then analyze how this might play out in the upcoming midterm. My goal is to provide insight to both sides of the pendulum, to remember that what matters most is a right–unlike the Second Amendment–not found in the Constitution: the right to life.


Addressing Both Sides

If you lean on the side against gun reform, you might argue that Dicken is emblematic of why we should not have a gun control policy. You might say that people kill people, not guns. That has been a slogan used by the NRA for quite some time. It is a truism. People kill people with guns. However, it is clever wording. If you gravitate towards gun reform, then the Uvalde massacre and the school shootings in the U.S. reveal how the phenomenon is unique to this nation. There were 288 school shootings in the United States between 2009 and 2018. At this same time, there were 2 in Canada, 2 in France, 1 in Germany, and none in the UK. The United States is the outlier. 

What is interesting about the gun reform debate is that both sides want to protect life, emphasizing different points of view. Anti-gun reform advocates argue that criminals will get access to a gun regardless. In contrast, those who propose gun reform say that guns are fundamentally destructive, and more circulation provides a means for more destruction. Both Fox News and CNN praised Dicken. Fox News reported that Dick was a ‘good Samaritan’ and emphasized how bad the event could have been without him. CNN described his heroism, expressing the same sentiment as Fox News. However, CNN expands on this notion in discussing how this is an outlier. Nearly 70% of the article is dedicated to Dicken’s case being the exception rather than the rule. They state, “Making Dicken's heroism perhaps even more remarkable is the fact cases of an armed bystander attacking an active shooter are rare.” The article references a New York Times study that illustrates how “armed people at the scene who are not law enforcement members can create confusion and carry dire risks.” However, the CNN article ends the article with a sentence describing his heroism once more. 

Media and Politics: 2022 Midterms

CNN leans left, and Fox News leans right. CNN, leaning left, leans towards gun control. Fox News, leaning right, leans towards no gun control. Dicken’s heroism provides Republicans with an argument against gun control. Uvalde and the tragically high number of school shootings in the U.S. offer Democrats cause for reform. Still, CNN’s article is kitsch. Dicken’s heroism was not the focus, yet because of this newsworthy story and widespread circulation, CNN had to report on the matter. A story that benefits the right’s political agenda is not conducive to gaining support from CNN’s critical demographic. The article on Dicken acknowledges his heroism, but the leitmotif of the story is the rarity of this occurrence. Though, CNN rightly notes this is a rare occurrence. However, it begs the question: would it be less rare if more states and good samaritans had a constitutional carry? The answer lies somewhere in the middle. Gun reform is not a simple conversation. When politicians and media outlets fall ill to the reductio ad absurdum, stating that if you are against gun control, you are for murder, we cannot make progress. I suspect Republicans will use the Indiana example in the upcoming midterm. Though it is an outlier in mass shootings, it is a brutal story to counter. Yet, Democrats will be able to rally around reform to stop school shootings, with gun control as the proxy for this feat. As Fox News and CNN cater to Republican and Democrat audiences, reporting will likely follow suit. This is an example of selection bias for audiences, news media, and politicians. We will see this story play out in the 2022 midterms.
A Challenge for Both Sides

Gun reform is highly polarized, and both sides are reluctant to compromise. I will challenge both sides of the pendulum. If you believe we need less gun control, how do you respond to the number of school shootings in the United States, which are astronomical compared to the rest of the world? If you believe we need more gun control, how do you respond to good citizens like Elisjsha Dicken, who saved countless lives because he was carrying? 

Equilibrium 
This is the last Pendulum Times article. I want to end this piece by stressing what I have done since this project began. We need to find equilibrium. When politicians and media outlets sensationalize, fragment, frame, and sensationalize reports, the electorate is left polarized. Currently, the Pendulum continues to swing further left and right. American democracy places the burden for change on us. As the people, we are responsible for bringing equilibrium to the political Pendulum. So why did I choose the Second Amendment debate for the last conversation? This topic illustrates how two diverging viewpoints are at an equilibrium that is not emphasized. Both sides seek to protect life, each getting at this sentiment from different sides of the Pendulum. Negative liberty is paramount in this nation—the American ideal's crux of the right to life, liberty, and property. I encourage you to see your neighbor as a fellow citizen, not through a political lens. If you disagree with someone on gun control, abortion, media censorship, voting laws, or healthcare, remember that your perspective has the same underpinnings as their point of view. We are all faced with uncertainty. We all share the same home: Earth. We often forget to place our position in perspective. My goal for this blog was to find points of equilibrium. Remembering that we are all citizens of Earth is a point of equilibrium worthy of discussion in concluding this project. I will leave you this photo from the James Webb Space Telescope of the Universe. When you place the political Pendulum against the universe, it is hard not to think of all people on Earth collectively.


Equilibrium requires gravity... 





Comments

  1. I thought it was really cool that you mentioned how CNN and Fox were both so supportive of the man that took down the shooter. You also did an exceptional job providing substantial reasoning behind both points of view on gun reform. I got chills reading your closing remarks. I agree with you entirely and appreciate the goal of your blog. Your message is truly remarkable and you did an impressive job communicating it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gun control is a sensitive subject, but in light of recent shootings, I felt compelled to express my own viewpoint. Please continue reading if you think that making guns illegal would end gun violence and shootings.

      In Florida, all you need to do to buy a gun is fill out the background check forms, show a valid form of identification, and be 18 or older. The gun dealer will get in touch with you three days after the background check is submitted to let you know if you qualify. You enter and buy a gun if you qualify. I'm done now. frighteningly simple Both a handgun and a concealed weapon permit require that the applicant be at least 21 years old.

      Delete
    2. I agree that both sides pander to their perspective audience and what topics and issues get discussed depends on what News channel you tune into. I spoke about this briefly in my article about the January 6th hearings and how both sides paint the hearing investigation differently. This sort of pandering can become dangerous because it firs helps stoke the fires of polarization but also dilutes the waters on rather it is true news reporting or simply opinion pieces.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Twitter

Recent Comments